MACP ON PROMITIONAL
HIERARCHY
Case No 21803/2014
Updates of today's/Final hearing-
Advocate C K Sasi
(AOR), who was well briefed by us, argued the case for M V Mohanan Nair. Advocates, representing to other respondents also done commendable job. Actually it was a well organised team work. Amicus Curiae presented the case extremely well. He also submitted a written
statement of his arguments to the court. As a result, the court realized the following:
1)
There are
anomalies in MACP scheme as evident from Minutes of Meeting of Anomaly
Committee.
2)
These anomalies
are affecting Group B & C employees and no impact on Group A.
3)
These anomalies
have life long impact.
Arguments have been
completed and the case is now reserved for orders. We expect a judgment
allowing MACP on promotional hierarchy.
Thanks
for Steering Committee
MACP on Promotional
hierarchy
We r in hope. Lets wait w& until final orders
ReplyDeleteThanks, hope for the best
ReplyDeleteWHAT IS THE JUDGEMENT DATE SIR
ReplyDeleteWe deserve the verdict in our favour. Hope for the same.
ReplyDeleteHOPE THE BEST.
ReplyDeleteउपरोक्त वाद में माननीय उच्चतम न्यायालय के आदेश का बहुत से पीडीत कर्मचारी इंतजार कर रहे हैं, आशा है माननीय उच्चतम न्यायालय सभी पीडित कर्मचारियों के साथ न्याय करेगा।
ReplyDelete1:39 AM
ReplyDeleteI AM VERY MUCH EXCITED OF THE ABOVE MACP PROMITIONAL HIERARCHY FINAL ORDER. MY LAST MACP ON 01.9.2008 AND MY DATE OF SUPERANNUATION ON 31.01.2019 WITH SAME POST I.E,UDC. MERA RAAT KA NEED GAYA. SOCHTE SOCHTE HEART KHARAP HO GAYA. MERE KO PACEMAKER BITHANA PADA. AGAR ABHI KUCH NAHIN HUA TO SACH MUCH MARH JAYENGE.
Thik tara lekho bandhu English hindi sob ko eksath mixed matkoro bengali babu.
DeleteDada, have faith in God. Justice is ofcourse delayed but never denied. We have faught with full force and dedication, thhe outcome has to be positive
DeleteAlways be positive in future ok
ReplyDeleteI am gr b but every time in pay commission gr c especially ldcs are neglected. i joined as ldc so i realize. Hope court will give positive judgement.
ReplyDeleteWill there be a further appeal chance for both ( petitioner and respondent) in judiciary process of apex court. Pl explain
ReplyDeleteI am also one of the severely affected staff by this MACP Scheme. If the verdict is positive I will be very much thankful for the Steering Committee as well as to the Hon'ble SC Judges. But the Judgement should be clear i.e. it is applicable to all CG Servants with retrospective effect. Lets pray God for a positive Verdict...
ReplyDeleteI joined cghs as ldc now i am looking after the work of accountant i am ddo maker i am ddo checker ...i draft letters i do typing work...i prepared salary bill contingent bill... With gp 1900 even a postman got 2000 grade pay...we ldc are the most oppressed employee
ReplyDeleteI joined as ldc in Nov 1988,I was offered a promotion in 2005 in Goa,which I declined as I stay in Mumbai,being a single parent had two young daughters to look after,my second macp was due in 2008,but I was given macp benefits in 2012 along with promotion of udc, didn't get arrears of grade pay from 2008 I was told I m debarred as I didn't except d promotion offer in 2005,I again got 3rd macp in 2019 instead of 2018 the reason same debarred for one year as I didn't accept d 2005 offer,debar period is hopesaid to be for one year only,but my entire career has been affected due to wrong judgement,hope the verdict justifies my issues.
ReplyDeleteHope decision for every Central government employees.
ReplyDeleteOnly group C and group B employees are affected due to various pay scales 1900, 2400, 4200, 4600, 4800, there so there' are lot of anomlies in 6 pay commission. I hope MACP on promotional hierarchy and not in next garde pay. And it should be implement for all C.G employees.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the next date of hearing for delivering the judgemet.Please
ReplyDeleteKnow any one
DeleteThink positive we hope judgement for macp in our favour
ReplyDeleteWhen will the court deliver the reserved judgement? Any date ?
ReplyDeleteHope for the best and decision should be in employees favour.
ReplyDeleteI am a person severely affected by the MACP Scheme. I got my 1st MACP from GP 1900 to Rs.2000/- after a Service of 10 years and got my 2nd MACP on completion of 20 years from Level 4 (GP 2400) to Level 5 (GP 2800) only. Hope that the Honourable Supreme Court's verdict is positive and giving a relief to all Central Govt. staff (Group C & B). I am keeping a track of all the developments in this case and I will be very much thankful for the Steering Committee for their continuous efforts. Let us all pray to God for a Positive Verdict in favour of the affected Employees.
ReplyDeletemacp cases listed for today in supreme court will not be taken up.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the next date of hearing
ReplyDeletenot yet updated on website
ReplyDeletewhat is the status of the case today
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLDC on 1991, UDC on 1995 Grade Pay Rs.2400 & Last and final MACP on 29.8.2008 Grade Pay Rs.2800. I have already completed 10 years service as the same MACP with same post i.e, UDC. I am very much excited about the above MACP PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY FINAL ORDER.Now I am a retiree but it's my only expectation is to provide me the MACP through PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY w.e.f. 01.09.2008 (grade pay Rs.4200).It's for your info. that in Rs.2800 grade pay I have completed 10 yrs of active service but I am not shifted to Rs.4200 grade pay as my department said I have already got three scheduled promotions.
ReplyDeleteI am a person severely affected by the MACP Scheme,I joined as ldc in Nov 1998,I was offered a promotion in 2018 in Mumbai which I declined as I stay in Other state ,being a single parent had two young children to look after,my second macp was due in 2018,but I was not given promotion as well as macp I was told I m debarred my entire career has been affected due to wrong judgement,hope the verdict justifies my issues.
ReplyDeletePillai Sir what is the update on judgement.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBY MISTAKE, I HAVE MENTIONED MY MACP LAST DATE 29.8.2008 INSTEAD OF 01.9.2008.
ReplyDeleteIt is a Great injustice to your Mr.PRADIP KUMAR BANDOPADHYAY. You should get another financial upgradation on completion 10 Years from 1.9.2018., ie., on 1.9.2018.
ReplyDeleteMacp on promotional heirarchy final verdict decesion order reserved on 29.01.2020. Now we should rely on the proverb"Slow and steady wins the race"Judiciary is supreme Authority.We hope for the best.
ReplyDeleteMacp upgradation from GP 5400 from PB-2 to GP 5400 PB-3 is Heatbreaking.
ReplyDeleteAlso Increment in PB-2 GP -5400 is more than Increment in PB-3 GP-5400 have a look.
Can anybody explain why in LDC group Timebound promotion is not given ?
ReplyDelete